The question is, what can we decide and what should people have complete control over themselves...
Well, first of all, one person (like Fiah) cannot decide anything about other people's (like Mudkipz) nations alone.
But what should be decided by majority vote? What should be decided by full consensus? What should we decide ourselves completely?
Before we can make an official map, we will have to figure that out. Otherwise the process of creating it will most likely become a messy anarchy.
Here are some suggestions:
Sizes: The size of nations relative to each other should be decided by majority rule if there is any disagreement.
Shape: The one making the nation can completely control the shape of the nation, as long as they use border thickness and the same colors as we've agreed upon (by majority vote) to make the map consistent.
Population: We ignore this matter in creating our map.
Dimensions: We decide the dimensions of the map by majority vote.
Resolution: Majority vote.
If any disagreement happens, we find a solution before continuing the work on the map.
Some things like dimensions and resolution should be decided before we begin working on the map.
So maybe, we should start by deciding the basic rules we use to make the official map if we want to make one. Then we can begin by continuing work on the other one or whatever. But I'm not going to participate if the process is going to continue like it has.