No need to be so critical. He probably doesn't want to say the person's name because he wants to be reasonable, and if you really want to know what's up maybe messaging would be better. No need to cause so much drama.
SpyCreepers, just because someone hates you doesn't mean the whole forum hates you. There's much more than a person than a community can have - if that person's giving you a problem, then I suggest bringing it up with a mod or someone trustworthy.